Driving
down a narrow twisting country road
in the Dordogne region of France most
tourists stop their cars to look at
the idyllic roadside pool overlooked
by a classical old French farmhouse
and watermill. Quietly signed as the
'Source de Coly', staring into the clear
blue water it's just possible to make
out the small dark archway from which
the underground water wells up into
the daylight. The submerged cave system
that stretches for many kilometres from
this tranquil spot has over the past
ten years seen some of the greatest
advances in underwater cave exploration
both in terms of distance explored and
the equipment & techniques used to accomplish
these dives.
The Doux de Coly cave was first dived
in the 1960's, but it was not until
1970 over a series of five dives that
P J Debras made any significant penetration
reaching a point 365m into the cave,
at a maximum depth of -52m.
In the early 1980's a Swiss team, Groupe
Lemanique de Plonger Souterrain (GLPS),
turned their attentions to the site.
This highly motivated team were bringing
a new approach to European cave diving
by using underwater scooters and stage
diving techniques to make significant
progress in many of mainland Europe's
classic cave-diving sites. In five days
in August 1981, a team of GLPS and French
cave divers pushed the Doux de Coly
to a point 1760m from the entrance -
mostly at depths of around -55m using
their underwater scooters. These allowed
faster movement through the cave, and
the use of less breathing gas than a
finning diver.
In 1983 the same team returned, and
the cave was pushed to 2100m, continuing
at similar depths. The following year,
'siege' tactics were employed, with
numerous dives being carried out to
allow the gradual establishment of relay
dumps (i.e. full gas tanks left at pre-arranged
points for the diver to use). These
stage dumps at 700m, 1100m & 1500m,
were augmented with extra emergency
bottle dumps at 550m, 900m & 1300m.
This system enabled the group's lead
diver, Olivier Isler, to continue with
the exploration to an amazing 3100m
from the entrance in a dive lasting
3 hours plus a further 8 hours of decompression.
Following this dive Olivier realized
that future explorations would not be
feasible using ordinary 'open circuit'
breathing equipment and began to look
at alternative systems. As a result,
following the 1984 expedition, Olivier
and his friend Alain 'Ron-Ron' Ronjat
(a French Naval Technician) set about
developing a semi-closed re-breather
system. This would recycle the diver's
exhaled breath - removing the carbon
dioxide and topping up as necessary
with new breathing gas. This would make
his gas supplies last five times longer
than on open-circuit gear. The RI 2000,
as it became known, was to prove the
key to future explorations at this and
other similar sites.
In the summer of 1989 Olivier and his
team returned to the Doux De Coly. They
made no real progress on this occasion
spending most of their time sorting
out teething problems with the new rebreather
system. Much of the work involved streamlining
the unit to enable it to be used at
speed with the Aquazepp scooters. No
further progress into the cave was achieved
but many lessons were learned which
would prove invaluable later on.
During this same period, a small number
of members of the British Cave Diving
Group (CDG) had also been visiting the
Dordogne area of France for a number
of years. The warm, clear water and
large cave passages contrasted sharply
with the small, cold, murky sumps found
back in Britain. On one such trip John
Cordingley had bumped into Olivier and
his team, and as a result John, Russell
Carter and Malc Foyle became involved
in Olivier's explorations at the Emergence
de Ressell in the Cele Valley. This
in turn led to a number of CDG members
- John, Russell, & Malc together with
Robin Brown, Brian 'Scoff' Schofield,
Brian Smith & Carol Tapley - being invited
along to participate in Olivier's 1991
Doux de Coly expedition. They were to
join with a twenty strong team of divers
from Switzerland, France and Belgium.
Because of the technical difficulties
and the specialized equipment used,
Olivier was the only diver able to push
on at the end. The nature of the expedition
was thus a little unusual in that it
involved many man-hours being expended
in order for one man to explore, alone,
the end of the known cave. The effect
of this was two-fold - it left Olivier
under enormous pressure to succeed,
whilst the other divers knew that they
were little more than supporters. Nevertheless,
Olivier was the first to acknowledge
the role that the rest of his team played
- likening the expedition to a space
mission where everyone played a vital
part, without which the end result could
not be achieved.
This 1991 expedition was a great success.
On his first push, Olivier reached a
point 3800m into the sump, of which
a significant part still lay below fifty
metres depth. A few days later a second
push was mounted during which he reached
a point 4055m from the entrance, smashing
the world record for the longest single
sump. On this dive Olivier spent some
14 hours underwater. And the cave still
continued...
The RI 2000 and twinned Aquazepps proved
themselves on the 1991 expedition but
possibly the biggest single technological
advance on this dive was Olivier's decision
to use an underwater habitat, to make
his nine hours of decompression safer
and more comfortable. This had been
done previously in Florida cave entrances
but the nature of the Doux de Coly meant
that the habitat had to be placed a
long distance inside the cave system,
something which had never been attempted
before. The habitat was a large inverted
metal tank with a ballast bin attached
below. Fitted with a fold down seat,
it formed a small airbell, which allowed
the diver to get his chest and head
out of the water. It was placed some
300m from the entrance, in the shaft
that descended vertically from -3m to
-43m. Attached by a complex rope system,
the habitat's buoyancy meant it could
be raised in stages up the shaft, as
Olivier's decompression progressed.
This combination of a relatively
comfortable decompression facility,
the Aquazepp scooters and the RI 2000
rebreather enabled Olivier to push forward
the boundaries of cave exploration still
further, but things were not to finish
here - the cave continued...
In 1997 Olivier returned to the Doux
De Coly but problems with the weather
and an accident with a scooter 2000
metres into the cave which resulted
in serious damage to the rebreather
meant that no further progress was made
on this occasion. The cave was however
extensively relined up to the 1500 metre
mark in preparation for another attempt
at a later date. That attempt eventually
came to fruition earlier this year when
a strong team of 10 British CDG divers
joined Olivier and 10 other Swiss and
French divers in the South of France.
The first week of the project was spent
on preparation. The main shaft 300 metres
in had to be rigged with decompression
lines, safety cylinders and the two
decompression habitats that were to
be used.
As well as Olivier, the German diver,
Reinhard Buchaly was also to make some
major penetration dives in support of
Olivier's attempt on the end. Reinhard's
approach to the dive was classic WKPP
style as adopted in Florida on their
recent record breaking dives at Wakulla
Springs. Rienhard was to dive using
a Halcyon rebreather and open circuit
bailout gas. Using this system effectively
as a solo diver unlike the WKPP divers
who always dive as part of a team, meant
that he was restricted by the amount
of bailout gas he could stage deep into
the cave and would not be able to reach
the end. He was however able to assist
Olivier greatly in the early stages
of the project, diving with him to the
3km mark, replacing sections of damaged
and broken line. Interestingly Reinhard
chooses to dive on Trimix using a fixed
depth decompression habitat whereas
Olivier uses Heliox and a variable depth
habitat. On their joint dive to 3000m
Rienhard left the water a full 2 hours
before Olivier although Olivier was
able to do virtually all his decompression
in the relative comfort of the habitat
while Rienhard had to do over 2 hours
in the water before he could enter his
habitat. Part of the reason for this
is that on his big pushing dives Olivier
chooses to run a saturation table which
gives him a predetermined 9.5 hour decompression
virtually regardless of bottom time
once he goes over a certain runtime.
Whilst this gives a very long decompression
it means that he has a very predict-
able schedule and very few restrictions
on the limits of exploration. The only
alternative would be to have to run
multiple dive profiles for different
scenarios as the nature of original
cave exploration like this is that no
one knows what the cave may choose to
do.
Both divers used heated undersuit systems
to combat the 12-degree water temperature,
plugging into external battery systems
on returning to the shaft. The new habitats
consisted of a neoprene chamber supported
by a ballistic nylon shell and an aluminum
framework. Rienhard's was attached directly
to the walls of the shaft using rock
anchors whilst Olivier's, which was
larger, was connected via a tirfor winch
to cables and ropes anchored to a large
car sized boulder at the base of the
shaft. Olivier is unable to easily remove
the RI 2000 unit underwater and wears
it for the entire duration of his dives.
External cylinders of decompression
gas are plugged directly into the unit
thereby maintaining the advantage of
the rebreather system even through the
decompression phase of the dive. Rienhard
removes his Halcyon unit prior to entering
his habitat and does the decompression
from then on using open circuit gas.
This he admits is the most dangerous
part of the dive for him. Removing all
your life support systems whilst hanging
part way down a 50m deep shaft, 300
metres inside a cave has to rate as
pretty dangerous in anyone's book! The
main risk is in dropping something (like
the rebreather), or losing control of
buoyancy whilst removing such a heavy
piece of equipment. For this reason
two minders would always be with him
whenever he entered the habitat or left
it. In practice whenever either of the
two lead divers were doing long decompressions
or using the habitats at least one support
diver would also be on standby in the
shaft. Some of these babysitting stints
would last up to three hours. Doing
long decompressions is bad enough but
it felt very strange to be doing the
decompression stops for someone else's
dive!
After almost two weeks work rigging
the cave, replacing and repairing lines
and installing and testing the habitats
Olivier was finally ready for the big
dive. Early in the morning two huge
U.S. style scooters similar to those
designed by Bill Gavin and used by the
WKPP were swum into the cave and placed
at the deep point at a depth of 60m,
350m from the entrance, a short way
beyond the shaft. The habitat was also
moved to its deepest decompression depth
at 18 metres.
During the morning Olivier assembled
the RI 2000 unit at the waters edge.
A triple redundant rebreather system,
it incorporates 2 x 20L cylinders and
2 x 12.5L into the rig itself and via
high pressure connectors can be supplied
with an infinite amount of gas from
external tanks. The back-mounted unit
contains two independent rebreathers
and the cylinders whilst the front-mounted
ventral unit gives the third independent
system. Any of these 3 systems combined
with any one of the four cylinders carried,
has more than enough capacity to get
the diver home from the furthest point
of penetration. Breathing gas used is
Heliox 25 in all four cylinders with
Nitrox and pure Oxygen plugged in as
required for decompression. The max
PPO2 is maintained between 1.2 & 1.6.
Unlike most rebreathers the unit measures
the diver's work rate by a system of
electromagnetic valves which measure
the volume of gas the diver is breathing
through the loop, adding extra gas as
required. Each system uses twin injectors
in case of failures.
The breathing bags are inside the unit
for protection and mimic exactly the
diver's own lungs to give minimum breathing
resistance. Each unit uses a 3.5L scrubber
canister (split into two on the ventral
unit for a lower profile) giving a minimum
of 10 hours run time on each of the
three units. Designed specifically for
Olivier's cave exploration projects
over a period of 5 years it took over
5000 hours to design and build and weighs
a colossal 110kg in air! To date Olivier's
deepest dive using the RI 2000 has been
-155m but with a glint in his eye he
told me he has plans...
At 1:00pm Olivier left the sunshine
and the assembled onlookers surrounding
the Doux de Coly sump pool and supported
by one other diver headed off into the
cave. Dumping his small transit scooter
at the shaft head he dropped into the
depths below, picked up the previously
staged primary and backup scooters and
headed off into darkness alone. A small
Hyball ROV (remote operated vehicle)
had been previously positioned in the
shaft at -35m to await his return and
monitor the decompression phase of the
dive. After 4 hours of watching an empty
shaft the tension started to build,
as did the number of team members gathered
around the small surface video monitor
relaying pictures from the ROV. Even
though everybody knew that the expected
bottom time was going to be anything
from 4 to 6 hrs (although rumours abounded
amongst the team that Olivier had the
capacity for up to 8 hours and might
just use it) things started to get quite
tense after 5 hours. The tension evaporated
when 5 hours and forty minutes after
he left the shaft bubbles and lights
on the video monitor signaled Olivier's
return.
Support divers immediately entered the
water to check that all was well and
found Olivier happily hanging in the
shaft connected to his decompression
cylinders and no doubt contemplating
the 9.5 hour schedule ahead. All had
apparently gone well although at this
stage he was not letting on how far
he had gone. I took the opportunity
to snap some quick shots as he made
the short deeper stops and with little
else to do and nowhere to go he posed
obligingly. After 1:15 mins he made
the transfer into the habitat where
finally after nearly 7 hours underwater
he was able to momentarily remove his
mouthpiece, take a drink and speak to
the surface using the habitat's telephone
system. The habitat maintains an air
atmosphere at all times in case of an
Oxygen convulsion during the decompression
so the relief of removing the mouthpiece
was short lived as all the remaining
decompression had to be done using the
RI 2000.
The next 8 hours proved traumatic for
Olivier who described them as the worst
hours he had spent underwater. Too tired
to operate the very stiff tirfor winch
which raised the habitat up the shaft
he had to rely on support divers to
make the moves for him and numerous
small problems occurred with hose routings
and location of the deco cylinders.
The most dangerous manoeuver came however
right at the end as he attempted to
leave the habitat. He had previously
passed out a list of instructions for
how he wanted to make this move but
it didn't help much as they were written
in French and neither Dave Ryall nor
myself who were on babysitting duty
at the time understand much written
French! After passing back in another
slate asking for instructions in English
the whole page of French suddenly got
condensed into two words - 15 mins!
At this stage my time was up and I left
for the surface ready to photograph
the triumphant return, leaving the departure
procedure in the capable hands of Dave
and Russell Carter who had arrived to
relieve me.
The problems with hoses and deco cylinders
compounded themselves as Olivier left
the habitat and at one point he was
left with no other choice than to totally
disconnect from everything, leave the
habitat and then reconnect to his final
deco mix. Totally exhausted after 15
hours in the water he had to be helped
across to the top of the shaft and the
waiting scooter ride back to the entrance.
Escorted by the support divers he eventually
emerged into the glare of video lights
and camera flashes at 4:30am, cold,
and totally exhausted, but successful
after a dive lasting 15.5 hours. From
his previous end point in a blind chamber
at 4km from the entrance he had relocated
the way on at 3.9 km and had pushed
the cave to 4.25km - a total dive distance
of 8.5 km! The bottom time was 5 hour
40mins at a maximum depth of 60 metres,
with a further 9 hours 30 mins decompression.
The RI 2000 though now nearly ten years
old proved itself yet again as the ultimate
cave diving exploration tool. For the
entire bottom time of over 5 1/2 hours
the unit only required 5.1 cubic meters
of gas, which equates to just thirds
on the integral 20L cylinders. The two
12L cylinders were left untouched!
It wasn't the longest cave dive ever
- that record rests firmly with the
WKPP project diving at Wakulla Springs
in Florida who have now touched the
6km mark. But all caves are different
and Olivier's dive is certainly on a
par with those being done in the U.S.
Permission to dive the Doux de Coly
is not readily given with access granted
only every couple of years in return
for large sums of money making familiarization
with the site and the continuity of
the exploration very difficult. The
water temperature is 12 degrees compared
to rather more diver friendly 22 degrees
in Florida and probably most importantly,
both logistically and psychologically,
due to the nature of the cave the decompression
has to be done inside the cave, a long
way from the entrance. Equipment and
technology are important at this level
of cave exploration no doubt, but equipment
is available to all and is only a tool.
Attitude, psychology and the right mindset
are far more important than any number
of toys and in this Olivier is surely
a breed apart.
By
Gavin Newman.